Replace Your Recruiters With Marketers

Marketing

Let me start by saying I have a lot of respect for recruiters. I have been a recruiter. I have led teams of recruiters. I have many friends who are recruiters. Recruiting is a critical part of building an organization’s talent pipeline… and this is why I believe we should replace a recruiting mindset with a marketing mindset. A recruiting mindset focuses on process and procedures. A marketing mindset focuses on the customer and creating connection. Marketing at it’s core is the process of identifying, anticipating, and satisfying the customer’s wants and needs better than the competition. In today’s social media world, a bad hiring process could be your Pepsi commercial. Your candidate is often also your customer -or was. According to a recent survey of over 1,000 recent job candidates, 64% of job seekers say that a poor candidate experience would make them less likely to purchase goods and services from that employer. One-third of the job seekers post about their poor experience on social media. So how can you create a marketing mindset for your recruiting team? Integrate marketing fundamentals in your recruiting — identify your target audience, anticipate their wants, and satisfy their needs.

Identify your target audience. Who are you trying to reach? What do they do? What is important to them? If you are looking to find top performing salespeople to join your organization, your interview scheduling needs to be flexible (because what they do is work and travel) and brief (because what is important to them is selling not interviewing). Looking for innovation leaders to transform your R/D department? What do they experience during your interview process? Is it innovative or are you having them sit in a conference room for four hours to conduct panel interviews? Redesigning your interviewing approach through the eyes of your target audience can be a powerful differentiator.

Anticipate wants.  Your candidate is a candidate for a reason- there is something they are seeking. Find out what it is. If he has had a progressive career in human resources including merger and acquisition work, mention your open change management leadership role. If she has a strong finance background and also lists several non-profit boards on her resume, what about that opening in your philanthropy organization? Most professional job skills are transferable- figuring out how to connect experience and passion is transformative.

Satisfy needs. Satisfaction is the fulfillment of one’s wishes, expectations, or needs. One of the most fundamental expectations of candidates is that they will hear from you in a timely manner about the next stages of the process. When you check on the status of your Amazon order would you be satisfied with the reply, “I meant to follow up with the manager on that but we’ve been so busy. I have a bunch of orders I am working on.”  Timely is hours or days, not days or weeks in the candidate’s eyes. Most candidates are hoping for an advancement when taking a new job – either in salary, title, or scope. So even if you can squeeze the person into a lower salary band or if their title could map to a lower title in your organization, will that satisfy the candidate? Will they be a brand ambassador or antagonist based on their experience? 55% of job seekers who have read a negative review have decided against applying for a position at that company.  So saving pennies can cost you your brand.

According to a recent survey, 97% of employers plan to invest in employment branding in 2017 and a majority (51%) plan to increase their spending from last year. Yet very few are taking an integrated marketing approach to recruiting. The candidate experience and recruiting process are going to be connected to your organizational brand — the question is are you going to manage those impressions or learn about them on Glassdoor?  So free your recruiting team from their requisition chains and empower their marketing superpowers so they can identify, anticipate, and satisfy your candidate and customer better than your competition.

 

Expand Your Learning Menu

cooking-college.jpg

What do cream of celery soup, potato chip tuna casserole, and broiled grapefruit have in common? Believe it or not, they were all listed as some of the most popular dishes to serve — in the 1950s.  The question is how do these items align with the interests and tastes of today’s customer? Let’s apply that same lens to your L/D offerings. Many companies are still serving up training content in the same way they did in the 1950s – expensive week long offsite session, instruction led lectures, and best of all big three ring binders. Does this learning approach align to the interests and tastes of your customers? I spoke about serving up bite sized learning at today’s Twin Cities SHRM Conference (#TCHRA.org) and we discussed understanding your customers’ palates, expanding your learning menu, and setting up a test kitchen.

Understanding your customers’ palates. I am a journalism major and remember that there was a time when breaking news came from newspapers.  Today it is comical to think that breaking news could be 24 hours old. But newspapers still play an important role in the world news. They bring the research and interview expertise and have the space to cover topics in depth. They are also still a viable source of news- a Pew Research study in 2016 found that 36% of U.S. adults got election news from a print newspaper. But papers don’t have the timeliness, flexibility, or portability to serve all the demands of today’s consumer. I would argue that the same is true of classroom leadership programs. These trainings can be incredibly valuable and give learners time to go deep on critical topics. But the reality is this approach alone doesn’t have the timeliness, flexibility, or portability to serve all the demands of busy leaders.  News now comes from a variety of mediums. I encourage you to think about how you can supplement your in-person training content with leader led discussions, short video clips, and/or other formats.

Expanding Your Learning Menu. When we talk about learning we often talk about the 70/20/10 model: that seventy percent of learning should be on the job, 20% should come from mentors, and 10% should come from classroom learning. The reality in many organizations is that 90% of IDPs focus on signing up for a class. So while we work on balancing our overall portfolio, how can we expand our menu of learning offerings? The good news is there are a lot of great resources out there.  Get Abstracts  summarizes thousands of business books. The Lean In website has a library of expert speakers.  Ted Talks is a website full of “ideas worth spreading.” The provided Ted Talk link is to a particular talk by Ramsey Musallam and three rules to spark learning. His talk is on chemistry- but his points can be applied to any topic. When presenting a topic, remind yourself of the following:

  1. Curiosity comes first. You can tell your audience or you can engage and inspire your audience- design for discussion.
  2. Embrace the mess. We spend a lot of time talking about theory but not enough time talking about what really happens when you try to put it into practice. Engage your audience to tell you their real experiences, fears, and successes when putting concepts into practice.
  3. Practice reflection. Help your learners reflect as they go, so they can see that each step forward- and step backward- is all part of the learning journey. Encourage them to journal, or set up check-in calls with a partner to keep the learning alive.

Set up a test kitchen. Here are two great ways to move your learning approach into a test kitchen. One is to use a flipped classroom approach to your content.  Traditional classrooms have lectures during the day, and homework at night. A flipped classroom asks kids to absorb the learning through online content, then uses the classroom time to talk about questions, insights and applications.  Think about how much more your classroom can be if you aren’t focused on pushing out content, but rather building on the team’s collective learning and understanding. Another non-traditional learning approach is an unconference.  Most conferences are built around pre-selected topics and speakers. At an unconference the attendees decide that morning what gets covered. Let’s say, for example, you wanted to cover the topic of interviewing with your managers.  This time, instead of preparing content you would kick off the session by asking the audience questions like, “What do you want to know about interviewing?”

“Where are you getting stuck in the interview process?”

“What have you learned that we would all benefit from knowing about interviewing?”

You may get responses like, “I want to understand more about unconscious bias.”

“I’m getting stuck assessing both technical and leadership skills.”

“I have finally figured out the best way to prepare for my interviews.”

Voila. You now have today’s topics. Scary? Maybe. But memorable, engaging, and an item I would encourage you to at least rotate on your learning menu.

According to the 2013 Corporate Learning fact book, U.S. businesses spend more than $60 billion a year in employee development. I don’t think we can afford for that to be spent on potato chip tuna casserole. So go back into the kitchen and whip up some new approaches to learning that reflect your customers’ palates, expand your learning menu, and push you to test some new ideas.

Recruit+Repeat = Retain

Homerun

“Go big or go home” is a common rallying cry in sports and in business. This mentality inspires recruiters to find the talent needle in the haystack. It also fuels a recruiting industry that offers executive search, website optimization, and selection tools to help you go big to find top talent. Getting the right talent in the door is a critical part of building your talent pipeline and should be a big focus. But what happens after you go big and get home? What is your strategy to re-recruit and “go big” to retain your current employees? I was asked to speak on this topic at the Recruit, Retrain, and Retain seminar held this week in Minneapolis. I believe we need to recruit and re-recruit employees to retain them.The good news is the same pillars of recruiting- understanding the need, scouting talent, and closing the deal – also support retention.

Understanding the Need. Recruiters and hiring managers spend a lot of time distilling organization needs when they open a requisition. What would a home run candidate look like? What do we need on the field to win?  How can this hire make our team stronger? Most companies have developed some kind of intake process to define the need. However few have applied that same approach to their current employees. You can re-recruit your employees by understanding their needs. Tell your employees how glad you are that they are here – and now you want to know where you want to go. What would a home run career look like? What role can take you to the next base? What skills can make you more competitive? How can we play to your strengths?

Scouting Talent. We invest a lot of time and money to find great people. In sports and business, scouts hit the field to assess prospects’ skills, mental toughness, experience, and team fit.  If we are lucky we find the future phenom while we work for each hire to deepen our bench. But what about the talent already in our bullpen? You can rerecruit your employees by scouting internal talent. Expect managers to be coaches. Spend time in the batting cages to improve employees’ tactical skills so they can make key plays. Let employees tryout for different positions on your team. Think of your early career employees as your farm team – and your job as providing them the experience and training so they can move on to a higher level at a given point.

Closing the Deal.  The payoff comes once we get the candidate to sign on the bottom line. Great prospects often have multiple offers, so we work hard to sell the organization, make a competitive offer, and close our top picks. Just like the pros, it is important that we don’t lose sight of our internal line up while we wine and dine our future stars. Employees are free agents and can entertain offers from other teams as they decide if they want to renew, renegotiate, or resign from their current employment contract. You can re-recruit your employees by closing a new deal. Ask employees about their short term and long term goals. What kind of position and playing time do they want? Give feedback on how to get to those goals and commit to coaching them along the way.  Your current employees know your business and know your customer – the best deal is to help take the current bench from good to great.

Recruiting and retention are often viewed as opposite ends of the talent field. But good coaches realize we need to focus on our full roster to win. In the words of Vince Lombardi, winning means you are willing to go longer, work harder, and give more than anyone else – to both recruit and retain your employees.

The Tears and Fears of Change

FearOfChange

One of my favorite 80’s songs is “Change” by Tears for Fears. In the song Curt and Roland lament, “I did not have the time. I did not have the nerve. To ask you how you feel. Is this what you deserve?” When I hear this stanza, it makes me think of how well intended change initiatives often unfold. John Kotter’s research on organizational change found that 70 percent of transformational change initiatives fail (Harvard Business Review, 1995). The Towers Watson 2013 Change and Communication ROI Survey shows that only 25% of change initiatives achieve long term success.  Most of us can recall a recent change initiative at work that fell short of its initial promise. So why do we keep our needle in the same groove when we know it isn’t working? There are a number of effective change models and frameworks that outline the critical steps in a change process.  Where we often forget to focus is on the change preparation. What do we need to do before kicking off an organizational change?

Take the time and have the nerve. In Jim Collin’s book Good to Great he talks about how great companies get the right people in the right seats on the bus.  I couldn’t agree more. But before your change bus embarks on a new initiative ask the passengers if they have the time to take on the project. The “right people” are often the same people we ask to do everything.  How can this specific project take precedence over their other objectives? Why should it be their main focus? What will impact their pay and incentives — this initiative or their day job? If we don’t ask and evaluate these questions we can quickly steer the change off course before it leaves the parking lot. A real bus makes stops and lets people on and off. Before launching a change how can we give people permission to get on and off the project at different stages?  It take guts to say, I would love to help kick off the project but my lack of attention to detail and work demands will make me less effective in the next phase of the project. But imagine the impact we could have if we gave individuals that license.  Lack of time, passion, and commitment are common road bumps- or roadblocks- on the change path. Before hitting the gas, evaluate your team and their commitments carefully.

Ask how people feel and what results we deserve. Communication is a staple step in all change models. Understanding why change is needed is a critical element in changing behavior.  Unfortunately too many change communication plans seem pre-recorded, telling employees why a change is needed once the destination has been determined. What if instead we invite employees into our recording studio to help us lay down the track?  Asking for employee’s voices before decisions are finalized is powerful and insightful. It helps us hear both what they know and how they feel.  Before we invest time and resources in a change, it is critical to invest in listening to our teams.  What do they love about the current state? What do they hate? What do they wish for? What are they worried about? Understanding the emotional current state can provide invaluable insights on how to design the future state. While you’re having these discussions, take a deep breath and ask, “So what results do we deserve?” Be honest with yourself and encourage your employees to be honest with you. Have you underfunded or under resourced the project? If so, share the project timeline and ask what risks they see and what recommendations they have. Have you responded to the latest employee engagement feedback? If not, revisit the feedback with your employees and understand what they are looking for from you.  Leaders need follower-ship to make change stick. Have you examined other factors- internal or external- that are competing for airspace with this change?  Engage your employees in brainstorming how, given this reality, the change can be effective.

Change is hard work- and even harder if we don’t take the time to prepare effectively for it. So take some advice from Tears for Fears and take the time, have the nerve, and understand how people feel so you can move the needle and make change stick in your organization.

Aloha at Work

Let’s face it. Going to work is not like going on vacation. But that doesn’t mean we can’t bring the spirit of aloha to our organization. Most of us translate aloha as hello or goodbye. But in the Hawaiian language the real meaning of aloha is peace, love, and compassion- I extend aloha to you. Too often we take a short sighted aloha approach to talent – one focused on welcoming employees on their way in and exiting employees on their way out. What if instead we focused on the talent within our organization, cultivating a positive and empowering environment?

It’s clear a change is needed. According to the 2016 Gallup Survey, 51% of employees are looking for a new job.  Only 31.9% of workers are engaged in their job. The implications are astounding.  Study after study shows the correlation between engagement and customer satisfaction, productivity, and quality.  So before our top talent packs their bags, let’s unpack a new approach to talent – one that draws on the peace, love, and compassion elements of aloha. Here are three suggestions:

(1) Provide peace of mind.  Employees want to understand the business strategy and know that their work impacts organizational results. So let them! Show them how they make a difference. Ask for their input and act on it.  Collaborate with them to set clear objectives that drive both business results and their motivation.

(2) Know what your employees love.  I love the list of questions posed in David Hassell’s Mindreading 101: Questions to Ask Your Team Every Week. Ask your employees about their wins this week. Ask what you are doing, or should be doing, to make them more successful. Ask for their ideas on how to improve your products and services. By understanding what they love you can also evaluate what they hate and try to eliminate rules, processes, and communication practices that push down morale and productivity.

(3) Be compassionate. Webster’s defines compassion as  the sympathetic consciousness of others’ distress, together with a desire to alleviate it. Employees define it as my boss cares enough to listen to me and to give me honest feedback. Give employees your full attention when they express their frustration. Help them see the big picture. Coach them on what they might say or do differently next time.

Engagement isn’t about leis or luaus. It’s about making a difference for both our employees and our customers.  So before you head out on your next vacation, how might you bring some aloha to your workplace?

Mindfulness over Matter

“Life moves pretty fast. If you don’t stop and look around once in awhile, you could miss it.” I love this quote from the movie Ferris Bueller.  It rings true for me in my personal and professional life. I am a planner- I like to know what I have coming up and what needs to get done. I am also a strategist – what are we working towards and what will we need when we get there?  Both of these are useful skills that we often emphasize in leadership.  Unfortunately in today’s busy world we often overemphasize our lists and our plans and forget to focus on the present. In a world that is constantly buzzing, flashing, and tweeting, being present is a real challenge. It is hard to be mindful when your mind is full.  Here is why mindfulness matters to business and three steps you can take to move yourself and your team forward.

Jon Zabat-Zinn is an internationally recognized leader in mindfulness and meditation. He defines mindfulness as “paying attention in a particular way; on purpose, in the present moment and nonjudgmentally.” Imagine if your leaders spent one less hour doing email and instead, paid attention – on purpose and non-judgementally-  to feedback from their team.  What if when leaders met with customers, they were in the present moment. They could be listening to the question the customer wants to solve, instead of presenting a pre-prepared answer. Mindfulness is the essence of connection – it means showing the other person that you value their time, ideas, and your relationship. No business that plans to stay in business can be too busy for that.  So how do we break our current pattern? Here are some ideas:

(1) Find out what you are missing. Review recent customer data and employee engagement feedback. Ask your top talent and top customers how well your leaders listen to their feedback, respond to their needs, and understand their priorities. It doesn’t need to be a science project – a sample size will give you some valuable insights to start with.

(2) Stop. Look. Listen. Help your leaders reprogram their approach and their day.  Have them look at their calendar and discuss their findings. Encourage them to stop triple booking themselves- help them set up a reasonable schedule. Ask them to look at where their time is being spent. Help them break their week down into time spent on tasks (emails, PowerPoints), meetings, team development, customer engagement, and personal development. Ask how they would ideally like to be spending their time and help them look for ways to make those changes. Listen to their frustration when they tell you they can’t do it all and agree with them.  Give them permission to set a new paradigm where getting it all done is not the goal – the goal is responding to your employee/customer insights.

(3) Highlight successes and failures. Mindfulness is hard work. Share tips, tricks, and resources. Recognize managers who have set up best practices. Ask leaders – especially senior leaders- to share when they fall back into their old ways and what they missed as a result. New behaviors stick when they are reinforced and practiced.  Remeasure your customer and employee feedback in a few months and assess the impact. Ask your leaders if they feel more focused on, more responsive to, and more connected with their customers and their teams.

Investing in mindfulness can pay dividends in the form of increased employee and customer engagement. So go ahead- put the phone down and email away- stop and look around. You don’t want to miss it.

Leading Through Change- Put Your Own Oxygen Mask First

“Self care is not selfish. You can’t serve from an empty vessel.” Eleanor Brownn.

Embedded in every change initiative is the intent to breathe new life into the organization―to revitalize ways of thinking, behaving and working. But as leaders we often find ourselves in the crosswinds of multiple changes, caught between a team choking on the pace of change and wheezing on our own change fatigue. To successfully lead through change the first step is to take care of ourselves. I know, you’re thinking that’s funny – I am subsisting on coffee and my kid’s fruit snacks right now. But it’s not funny- it’s actually very serious. According to the July 12, 2016 Harvard Gazette, data show that 36 percent of workers suffer from work-related stress that costs U.S. businesses $30 billion a year in lost workdays. That does not include all the employees filled with stress and anxiety who are still at work but not fully productive. So what can you do?  I suggest taking a page from the airlines. On every flight we are reminded that in case of emergency we should put on our own oxygen mask before attempting to help others. Change is bumpy. We can’t navigate it safely if we are passed out. This Leading Through Change Self Assessment can serve as your oxygen mask. Take the assessment. Then commit to LEAD through change:

Look/Listen. Reflect on your results. What are they telling you?  How is that impacting your effectiveness at work? At home?

Engage.  Share the results with someone that can help support you in making changes in your current routines.

Act. What one thing will you do differently so you can lead your team through this change?  What does that look like? What is your next step? What is your timeline?

Dedicate Yourself. Then go do it and stick with it. Encourage your team to take this assessment and share their goals and results.

It’s a lot easier to talk about transformation than to actually do it – whether it is for ourselves or for our business. The good news is if we look at what we have learned, make course corrections, and focus on continuous learning, we will have the fuel needed to make positive change over the long haul.